READING LIST FOR THE 2022 STUDY GROUP: EXPLORING SOME KEY PAPERS OF WINNICOTT’S IN THE LIGHT OF THE PRESENT CLIMATE CRISIS.

SPRING TERM

24th January The Theory Of The Parent Infant Relationship (1960) in Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment

The fundamental importance of the facilitating environment where maternal holding meets the infant’s need for absolute dependence. In this paper Winnicott thinks that Freud (and Klein) take this provision for granted. Winnicott outlines some of the consequences of failure of good-enough provision. We too can no longer take the environment for granted, with possible parallel repercussions. Related to this is the universal fear of WOMAN and the attack on mother earth c.f. Primary Maternal Preoccupation (1956).

28th February Fear of Breakdown (1963) in Psychoanalytic Explorations (1989) eds Winnicott, C. & Shepherd, R.

Defences, particularly, depersonalisation, disintegration, autistic states, are viewed by Winnicott as defences against primitive agonies, breakdowns at the time of absolute dependency which cannot be consigned to the past because they have not been experienced (because the ego was too immature) and cannot be remembered. Fear of breakdown is a fear of a breakdown that has already happened. This includes fear of death which is really about an earlier annihilation, the concept of death being a relatively mature acquisition. Many of Winnicott’s examples were highly functioning individuals whose defences had allowed them to be successful but the hidden anxieties were of a psychotic nature. Could the consequences of our destruction of the environment be equated with the consequences of failures Winnicott describes at the time of absolute dependency? How can we articulate or even bear to think about them, even though they are happening now with mass migration, extreme weather? What sort of setting is necessary to be able to experience these psychotic anxieties?

28th March Ego Distortion in Terms of True and False Self (1960) in Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment

Winnicott describes a compromise between the True self and compliance necessary for social living but an excessive split between the True and False self leads to a failure of symbolisation, a poverty of cultural living and a search for impingements, living filled with reactions to impingements. Perhaps exceptionalism and entitlement e.g. “I need and deserve this luxury” are examples of this type of living. Excessive Impingement destroys the illusion necessary for healthy maturation whereby each external stimulus is met by a corresponding spontaneous gesture in the infant. Both the pandemic and Climate Crisis could be classed as massive impingements threatening to overwhelm our ego capacities.  For Winnicott compliance is the antithesis to healthy living.

SUMMER TERM

25th  April The Development of the Capacity for Concern (1963) in Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment

Concern implies care and responsibility. The attainment of ambivalence through bringing together the environment mother and the object mother, the importance of opportunities that the mother gives to her child for reparation and contributing, are highly relevant to the our response to the destruction we have wreaked on the Environment.This reworking of Klein’s Depressive Position affords a different way of viewing and, perhaps a more hopeful response to the Climate Crisis. 

23rd May The Use of an Object and Relating through Identifications (1968) in Playing and Reality (1971)

 This paper is a cumulation of Winnicott’s unique views on aggression. Aggression is innate and bound up with the life force and muscularity and motility, not a reaction to frustration towards Reality, but essential in establishing Reality. The infant needs to destroy in fantasy the mother as a bundle of projections (subjective object) and greet the mother who survives the attack as the mother of value who is an objective object, inaugurating Reality.  Destructiveness occurs if the object fails to survive. Despite our sophistication we could say that humanity has treated the non-human world as a ‘toilet breast’, a subjective object, with a disregard for objective reality.

27th June The Location of Cultural Experience in Playing and Reality (1971)

Imaginative play occurs in the intermediate area between inner psychic reality and external reality, between the subjective object and the object objectively perceived. This makes life worth living and is the basis of culture. Ben Okri[1] wrote recently that we need artists and writers to respond to the Climate Crisis. We must tackle the profound resistance to imagining a potential end wrought by our continuing destruction.

AUTUMN TERM

26th September Adolescence. Struggling through the Doldrums in The Family and Individual Development (1965)

Winnicott lists the needs of Adolescents: The need to avoid a false solution, the need to feel real, the need to defy and the need to prod society. Greta Thunberg and the young persons’ movement took the world by storm and uncomfortably held a mirror up to us, so called adults, who are behaving like children. 

24th October Boundary and Space: Part 111 of Boundary and Space (1981) eds Davis, M. and Wallbridge, D. pp143-174

Davis and Wallbridge examine the concepts of Boundaries and Space by helpfully bringing together several papers by Winnicott.  How does a study of individual development contribute to thinking about the response of society, its members and its leaders, to the ultimate existential threat?

28th November Plenary session and Conclusions


[1]  Guardian [newspaper] 17th October 2021